This has been an excellent thread to read! Knowing that opinions weigh heavily based on the experience you are looking for, if you have kids, and how much $$ you are willing to spend. I have enjoyed reading all the responses!

I have to say, for us, the excellent and outstanding far outweigh the sub-standard and the lousy.

DH says Cape May Cafe didn't do it for him. Being from New England, he expected more quality in the seafood. Service has always been great though. Yep, we do go back when we have first time guests with us who want to try it.

I say Sci-Fi Dine In Theater-bad food, small portion (thank goodness)and lousy service. We'll never go back there.

Rose and Crown was nothing to write home about either. DH missed that meal but Mom and I didn't enjoy ourselves. We ended up snacking before the night was over. Suppose we might try it again if someone in our party really wanted to.