Brett Favre, ughhhh.....

[gueli]

Ian - you misunderstand me.
I am not upset that you believe that eli manning should not have been the mvp. I am upset with your wording specifically calling him a fraud.
perhaps I did not explain this well, but to me stating that "never has there been a bigger fraud of a Super Bowl MVP than Eli Manning" implies that Eli Manning is a fraud.
In what way? That he won the mvp? how did he commit the fraud?
If you had said something like I think its a Sham that they gave Eli Manning the MVP award- I have no problem with what you are saying, I might disagree (I might not), but to me use of the word fraud imples some implcit wrongdoing on eli's part. Was I misunderstanding and taking offense to something that you did not mean (That eli commited fraud)?
I have no problem with you having an opinion that disagrees with my own. I enjoy a well meaning discussion of differing opinions. Usually I listen fairly, and make up my own mind, and actually this post (Bret Favre) over the course of the season has turned me from believing that bret would help the Jets more than he would hurt them, to one where he has hurt them at the most inopertune times.

But one final Question Ian, in your opinion who deserved the Giants Superbowl MVP last season? obviosly you think eli did not.

Now from my perspective, I agree with Pagan- that up untill that clutch escape by eli, on that final drive he would not be the MVP.

Well anyway-

Happy New year one & all.


Go Jets. Because Win,loose Die or tie- I will keep rooting for them. (and I hate when they die).
Gueli

[Ian]

.. perhaps I did not explain this well, but to me stating that "never has there been a bigger fraud of a Super Bowl MVP than Eli Manning" implies that Eli Manning is a fraud ...

Okay ... I gotcha now.

It's a problem with my phrasing not yours.

I didn't mean that Eli was a fraud. I meant that the NFL's action of awarding the MVP award to Eli was fraudulent.

Sorry for confusion!

[gueli]

OK
not a problem.
Thank you for the clairification.


Happy New Year