Ben Roethlisberger or Eli Manning?

[eeyorelover63]

Who do you think is a better QB? they were both drafted the same year(2004) and both have a Super Bowl Ring. Who would you rather have on your team?

[SBETigg]

I can't stand Eli, so I would choose Ben given a choice between the two. Of course, I would have lost today's game with that choice, but I stand by it.

[kakn7294]

Despite what happened today, I'd take Ben in a heartbeat.

[Ian]

Despite the Super Bowl win, I don't think Roethlisberger has ever lived up to his hype. He started out that rookie season on fire, but ever since he's been pretty average.

Eli, on the other hand (as much as it pains me to say this), at least seems to be progressing in his development.

I'd take Eli.

[JPL]

Well with the bias of a Giants Fan I have to say Eli all the way. He seems to have that something extra which translates into winning. Now had you asked me this time last year my answer may have been a little different

[joanna71985]

Eli all the way!