Birthday Dinner Suggestion (SOS)!

[Arielfan98]

Hello all,

I am excited to announce that within 24 hours of intense planning/preparation I am going to Disney for my birthday in January from the 2nd-6th

I am going with my sister, and we are doing a cheap Disney trip. Normally we do the dining plan, but we decided it's cheaper to share meals and splurge on one sit-down dinner to celebrate my birthday. With this in mind, I need your help!

Which sit-down to go to? I am looking for:
-Not too fancy restaurant (California Grill, Le Cellier, etc.)
-Characters or some special aspect to it (like viewing of Wishes)
-I would prefer a buffet or all you can eat style, but regular dining options are welcome
-It can be in a park, or in a hotel
-dinner

Here is what I am considering (but please suggest other places):
1. O'Hanas
2. Cape May
3. 1900 Park Fare
4. Garden Grill
5. Chef Mickey's

Any reviews, input, and suggestions are welcome! Thank you so much

[Fangorn]

Have you considered Tusker House. We are there a couple of weeks ago for dinner and the food was yummy (buffet) and the character interaction was the best I've ever experienced. We had a reservation for 6:30 which was one of the last times for the evening. It started clearing out shortly after we were seated, but the food never stopped being refreshed and the characters spent a lot of time with everyone since there were fewer guests.

You might also consider the Boathouse in Disney Springs. Not a buffet, but excellent food and sitting outside by the lake is great.

Have fun.

Steve

[Arielfan98]

Have you considered Tusker House. We are there a couple of weeks ago for dinner and the food was yummy (buffet) and the character interaction was the best I've ever experienced. We had a reservation for 6:30 which was one of the last times for the evening. It started clearing out shortly after we were seated, but the food never stopped being refreshed and the characters spent a lot of time with everyone since there were fewer guests.

You might also consider the Boathouse in Disney Springs. Not a buffet, but excellent food and sitting outside by the lake is great.

Have fun.

Steve

On a side note, we actually decided to skip AK, and are not crazy about Tusker House. Also, The Boathouse is a bit out of our price range.

[#1donaldfan]

If it were me I'd get rid of Chef Mickeys, it's just too crazy in there and not a great buffet. The rest you have lined up are great, esp Cape May. Look at the Plaza in MK .... it's a must-do for us each trip !!

[KarenP]

Crystal Palace is another character buffet that you may want to consider.

50's Primetime Cafe is a table service but it is very unique and a lot of fun.

[ibelieveindisneymagic]

Rose & Crown with Illuminations viewing! We've celebrated a couple birthdays there, and it has been wonderful.

Otherwise, Garden Grill is one of our favourites, and with the awesome character interaction, I think it would be a good place for a birthday.

[Zippy 1]

We just did Cape May for my birthday. They made it a great night. Food was awesome. Then our server brought out a great birthday treat and card signed by several characters. She then had everyone sing happy birthday to me. It was so much fun! We go there every trip

[MississippiDisneyFreak]

Out of your list I would pick O'hana's it is a must do for us. Also, not a buffet but a very nice place to dine is Narcossee's

[buzznwoodysmom]

Don't know if you made your decision yet, but I would pick Ohana. If I was to only pick one sit down meal for a Disney trip (birthday or not) it would be, without a doubt Ohana. Ohana for my birthday meal would be even better!!

[Arielfan98]

Awesome news guys! So after looking day after day we were able to snag O'Hana's at 7:50 PM right before the 8 PM Wishes! Also, we added on the Garden Grille for breakfast I can't wait! Thanks for the suggestions and reviews.