When my DW and I go to WDW in April for our 18th anniversary, we are going to try all new restaurants. Here's our list:

Be Our Guest
Mama Melrose
Narcoossee's
Jiko
Artist Point
Bistro de Paris
Olivia's Cafe
Yak and Yeti (TS)
Citrico's
Artist's Palate
Captain's Grille
Yachtsman Steakhouse

We've never eaten at any of these. Opinions? We like most different kinds of food, with the exception of fish. My DW hates seafood. I like shrimp, lobster, crab, scallops...but don't care for fish, either. Unless it's breaded and fried cod from the UK pavilion!