I'm a Silver Castaway Club member now, and I went on two DCL cruises this year. Both times, I got the lovely and fabulous club backpack with the nifty little keychain and some snacks in it. On the first cruise, I was silver but my companion was a first-timer. On the second cruise, my companion was also silver.

So here's my question: do you get the same exact gift four times until you hit gold status, or was this a fluke because of my weird situation?