I also didn't vote, because I have 3 that are always on my list. In no particular order, here they are:

Columbia Harbor House - Fish and Chips and the seating area on the second floor

Pecos Bill's - Fixings bar - sauteed mushrooms are the best

Casey's Corner - Hot dogs and sitting outside listening to the pianist while staring at the Castle - doesn't get any better

I also have a 4th favorite, but it's not on my "must" list for every visit - Cosmic Ray's - love the Sonny Eclipse "show"