Has anyone ever eaten for either for lunch or dinner.. I've been going to DISNEY for many years and only just found out this place existed
I would welcome your experiences of eating there
Many thanks
---------------------------------------------------------
Offsite 1996 to 2005
Dec 2006 2007 2008 CBR
Dec 2009 2010 2011 2013 2014 2017 BLT
Dec 2012 2015 2016 2018 OKW
Dec 2017 2018 S/S
June 2010 BCV
June 2012 OKW
They used to do breakfast too which was my favorite time to eat at this location. Alas, breakfast is no more.
I've had mixed results when eating at this location. Sometimes it has been very good; other times, just okay.
Linda aka: Faline
INTERCOT Staff: Vacation Planning,Trip Reports and Disney Camping
faline@intercot.com
We have eaten there a couple of times and liked it. It's not the best place, but the food was good (not great) and I liked the atmosphere a lot. Not planning it for our next trip, but I am sure we will go there again.
DNS;2446468 wrote: We have eaten there a couple of times and liked it. It's not the best place, but the food was good (not great) and I liked the atmosphere a lot. Not planning it for our next trip, but I am sure we will go there again.
I agree with your comments completely, but would like to add that the meatballs at Tony's are exceptional. Really very very good!
Jennifer (aka Mickey'sGirl)
INTERCOT Staff: Guests with Special Needs, Dining and Disney Characters
Last trip: March 2016 - Fantasy
Next trip: Aug 2017 - Aulani
I am a Galactic Hero once more!
We've eaten there twice (both times walk up, no ADR). Both times were very good.
Jodie
We went there twice. The first time we were very impressed and couldn't wait to go back. The second time every pasta dish was over cooked and mushy and the marinara sauce tasted like they poured tomato sauce right out of a can. Very disappointing and we haven't been back since. We do hope that was just a one off and talk about risking it again because we had such a great first experience but haven't made it back.
Aryn
I am the rebel spy.
We like it there. Desserts are very good. Great location.:thumbsup:
Scallywag
August 2004 - POR
May 2006 - POF (Honeymoon Trip)
September 2006 - Royal Pacific (Universal Studios)
April 2007 - POR
July 2009 - CBR
June 2013 - CBR
June 2014 - POF
June 2016 - POLY
June 2017 - AKL
June 2018 - BC
We like it. We have eaten there a few times and know what we will experience. The food is pretty good and the location is really nice.
First WDW Trip 1984
30+ Trips since 1984
Disneyland 4 Visits
Disneyland Paris 2010
40th Wedding Anniversary December 2013
Disney Cruises 2: Magic 2005, Fantasy 2012
Last Trip November 2019
We have had good food and love the atmosphere. The service has been less than Disney quality. Not sure why but we have felt like we were on hidden camera or something. Just weird experiences. We would like to go back this summer because the location is great and the kids like the menu. The pistachio crème brulee is delicious!
"If you can dream it, you can do it."
We have eaten at Tony's many times.
I can say we have never had a "bad" meal there. Most everything is fairly good.
Some items fit into the "I can get this better at....' fill in the blank. For me that is the fried zucchini appetizer.
The steak is my fall back menu item, I've never gotten a bad one.
On our last visit my granddaughter had the chicken parm and I was very jealous, probably the best entrée I've ever tasted there.
Then we come to the Pistachio crème brulle! OMGosh! As a crème brulee fan this one ranks in the top 3 I've ever had.
KAY
DVC MEMBER - OKW & HHI
First trip to WDW - Dec, 2005
Last visit to Disneyland - 2014
First trip to Disneyland - 1955
The last time we were there, it was the absolute worst meal and experience we have ever had at any of the restaurants at WDW. We have never been back but that was a few years ago so maybe it has changed.
If you decide to give it a try, I would be interested in your experience as the location is one of the best.
Paula[/
It's an ok restaurant. I'm accustomed to authentic Italian cuisine because I live in southern NY, near NYC. It reminds me of Olive Garden. I will say that their pistachio creme brulee is out of this world, though. I think this place has a good value for a Disney restaurant--affordable for a casual sit down meal.
"I want to be apart of your world."
All Star Music 2000-present & future
I"m pretty lukewarm on Tony's. My husband loved his food when we went there but to me it had a definite frozen Italian meal feel.
The food wasn't bad but nothing memorable.
On the up side the atmosphere and the staff was very nice and there are really not a lot of great options for table service at Magic Kingdom.
For lunch I would pick Be Our Guest, The Plaza or the Liberty Tree Inn over Tony's. I'd be more likely to consider it for dinner if I were to go back.
Cindy aka AgentC
INTERCOT Staff: Accommodations, Dining, Movies, TV, Music & Musicals
Tony's gets a lot of hate, but it's really not as bad as people say. There are certainly better places to eat, but it's not bad. The atmosphere is nice, especially if you're a big Lady and the Tramp fan. I'd recommend that everyone should do it once. If you do go, do dinner. There are much better options for lunch.
Last Trip-April 2008-Boardwalk Inn
Next Trip-October 2017-POFQ
We've eaten there a few times and the food has been good everytime. The service however has been variable, ranging from a truly spectactular server who went out of her way to make the experience great to a truly horrible server who was only concerned about getting her tip and was moaning about everyone she was serving in earshot of the guests.
